Every year at Thanksgiving, people gather to spend time with friends and family to share a meal and company — often including beloved holiday programs and movies. Among the programs that have become beloved favorites is A Charlie Brown Thanksgiving.

A Charlie Brown Thanksgiving may be an annual viewing staple, but the wholesome Peanuts special is steeped in a terrifying debate: Is Woodstock a cannibal? As the years go on, the decades-long debate surrounding Woodstock’s consumption of turkey at Thanksgiving dinner is still raging.